The following question was asked on Quora:
Q: Who was the best representation of a Vulcan in the entire Star Trek Universe, bearing in mind their qualities as a species?”
A: I know it sounds trite but the answer is Spock, not just because he’s the most prominent Vulcan but because the entire species was designed around him.
The Vulcan species wasn’t very well-defined before the show aired. The original concept by Gene Roddenberry was completely different with Vulcans intended as red-skinned aliens with a plate in their stomach they would use to absorb energy. He also planned to make Spock’s “weakness” a “curiosity about all things alien.” Here’s the original concept art:
The logical and unemotional nature of the Vulcans that defines them wasn’t even in the original concept. In the first (rejected) pilot for the series, Spock can be seen laughing and smiling:
That’s because the second-in-command (Majel Barrett) was supposed to be the cold and logical one while Spock would be her counter-balance as the enthusiastic and emotional one. When her Number One character was cut, her logical nature was given to Spock, instead. The idea of Vulcans being green-blooded also came later because there were concerns Spock’s red skin would look black on black-and-white TVs that were more common at the time.
That’s the way the entire Vulcan race was defined: as changes made to accommodate Spock’s character. Another example is the Vulcan nerve pinch, which was developed because Leonard Nimoy objected to a scene in “The Enemy Within” where he was supposed to punch Kirk. He thought that was too undignified for a Vulcan, so he came up with the nerve pinch instead. Nimoy also came up with the Vulcan salute from an old Jewish ritual. By the time we saw other Vulcans on the original series for the first time in “Amok Time,” they were all based on Spock’s appearance and mannerisms.
TL:DR: Spock defined the Vulcan species, not the other way around.
What do you think of Spock?
We love your comments! But please be mindful of our comment policy.
If you enjoyed this, then please use the buttons below to tell your friends about this post! Follow us! Email | RSS | Twitter | Facebook
<span class="dsq-postid" data-dsqidentifier="31742 ">1 Comment
That's a good answer. In Harlan Ellison's script for City on the Edge of Forever he talks about how the network wanted Spock to look more human and even had flyers showing Spock with human ears and pinker skin before season 2. Ellison and fans protested the changes to keep Spock as is.